SNAPSHOT 1,039 PLAYING — 65.5M VISITS — 12 PER ROUND — CHECKED 2026-10-28 01:44 UTC
MOO MOO MYSTERY Play on Roblox

Moo Moo Mystery vs Murder Mystery 2

Last checked 2026-10-28.

Both are 12-player social deduction games on Roblox. Murder Mystery 2 was created in 2014, carries a Moderate maturity label, and had 416,253 playing in this snapshot, with Innocent, Sheriff, and Murderer roles plus knife trading. Moo Moo Mystery was created in 2025, is labeled Mild, had 1,039 playing, and uses Cow, Researcher, and Security with a shapeshift described by community sources.

First-person security view aiming at the cow holding a knife
Image: Roblox experience thumbnail, universe 7283491781. Checked 2026-10-28.
The cow holding a knife beside a character with a flower hat
Image: Roblox experience thumbnail, universe 7283491781. Checked 2026-10-28.

Side by side

Online and visits are the research snapshot, not live counters.

Moo Moo MysteryMurder Mystery 2
Universe728349178166654135
Created2025-02-232014-01-18
Max players1212
Online1,039416,253
Visits65,526,32031,884,035,918
MaturityMildModerate
CreatorBlοx UniverseNikilis
RolesCow, Researcher, SecurityInnocent, Sheriff, Murderer
WeaponsGun for Security, knife for the cowSheriff gun, murderer knife, knife trading
Round lengthNot publishedNot published

Who has an easier first round

Editorial comparison: Murder Mystery 2 has a decade of guides and a trading layer you can ignore. Moo Moo Mystery’s extra rule is the shapeshift, which is also the main tell. MM2 explicitly advertises knife trading; the checked Moo Moo Mystery description does not document the same feature. If a Moderate violence label is a problem, Murder Mystery 2’s label is the stricter of the two official labels in this snapshot.

What I checked

Official descriptions supply the role names and MM2 knife-trading feature. The table uses creation dates, not demonstrated release dates. Pace and learning difficulty are editorial considerations, not measured round times. All Roblox fields belong to one publisher; the 01:44 UTC counters are historical snapshots.

Questions

Are the roles the same?

No. Sheriff is not Security, and the cow transforms. Murder Mystery 2 uses Innocent, Sheriff, and Murderer.

Which one is free?

Both experience prices were null in the API sense used for this site. Passes and trades are separate.

Which has more players?

Murder Mystery 2, at 416,253 versus 1,039 in the 2026-10-28 research snapshot.

Sources